Cap Gun Collecting Themes: Western, Police, Pirate and More

Western, police, and pirate themed cap guns.
Deciding on a themed collection is a great way to start your cap gun hobby. | AI-Generated Image

Walk into a good collection and you'll notice something. It has a point of view. The pieces belong together, and you can see what the collector cares about.

That's what a theme does. It stops you buying random things, it makes your shelf look planned, and it gives you a reason to hunt for the next piece. A collectors' column in a US newspaper puts it simply: the criteria vary with the collector. Some pick a maker. Some pick a material. Others pick a time frame.

Here are the themes that work well for cap guns, with a few honest notes on what each involves.

Western

This is the classic. Cowboy cap guns, Colt-style toy revolvers, Peacemakers, lever-action rifles, holsters and badges. It's the theme most people think of first, and it's easy to start.

Western themed toys also give you lots of ways to build a display. A revolver, a holster, a sheriff's badge and a hat tell a story on their own. Our western revolvers and holsters ranges are a good place to look.

The legal side: realistic western toy guns can be classed as imitation firearms in Victoria, New South Wales, Tasmania, the Northern Territory and the ACT, so check your state first. Our permits page has the details.

Police

Revolvers and replica toy pistols with a law-enforcement look, often with a badge or a holster to match. It's a good theme if you like a bit of 1970s and 80s TV nostalgia, and it pairs well with western pieces for contrast.

See our police revolvers. The same state rules apply as for any realistic cap gun.

Pirate

Flintlock-style pistols have a swashbuckling look, and they stand out on a shelf. They're a fun theme for anyone who likes adventure stories.

Flintlock-style pieces also get treated differently in the permit states. Our FAQ says flintlocks are an exception, so a pirate collection can be an easier route into collecting in some places. Not every pirate-style piece is a true flintlock design though, so check each listing and ask us if you're unsure. Browse our pirate pistols.

Military

Pistols, machine gun styles and rifles with a wartime look. They appeal to people with an interest in military history, and our military pistols and machine guns ranges cover that ground.

This is the theme that needs the most care. Tasmania Police classify imitation machine guns as prohibited firearms that need an exemption, and in NSW an imitation of a prohibited firearm is treated as a prohibited firearm. If you want a Thompson, an Uzi or an AK-47 style, ring your state police first. We check permits before anything ships, and we'd much rather answer a question than process a refund.

By Maker

Some collectors follow a maker. It's neat, because you start to see how a company's style develops. Most of what we sell comes from three makers. Of the roughly 80 products at Cap Guns Australia, Gonher makes 46 and Schroedel makes 23, with Villa Giocattoli making up much of the rest.

On the vintage side, the collectors' column names Hubley, Kilgore, Mattel and Nichols among the factories of note. Collecting by maker is a good way to learn the marks.

By Era

Another option is to collect by time. The collectors' column calls the 1940s to 1960s the golden era for toy guns, with singing cowboys and TV westerns driving sales, and guns and holsters tied to famous stars. Others collect the 1970s and 80s, the toys many of today's collectors had as kids.

An era theme suits people who like history. It also helps you decide what to say no to.

By Size or Type

There are some practical ways to group pieces too. By shot count, for example. Of our listings, 35 are 8-shot models and 21 are 12-shot, so those two sizes are by far the most common. Or by type, such as pistols only, rifles only or holster sets.

These aren't themes in the storytelling sense, but they give a collection a clear rule, and that makes it easier to say what belongs.

Mixing Themes

You can mix. A cowboy shelf next to a pirate shelf is a fine way to run a display, as long as each has its own space. Group by theme, leave room between them and label them so visitors know what they're looking at.

If you're not sure, start with one theme and add another later. You'll learn what you like by buying one piece at a time.

Buying for a Collector

If you're shopping for someone who collects, you may be after novelty western gifts or cowboy gifts. It's a lovely idea, but there are two things to sort out first.

The person who ends up owning the piece is the one who needs to be legal. If they live in a permit state, they'll need approval before it arrives, and the permit needs to be in their name. Check the law in their state, not yours.

And find out their theme. A collector with a pirate shelf won't want a police revolver. A gift set from our gift sets range can be a safe choice for someone just getting started, but ask first.

How to Choose

Here's a simple way to pick. Think about what you enjoyed as a kid, or what you'd enjoy looking at every day. Then check your state's rules for that theme. Then buy one piece and see how it feels.

If you can't decide between two themes, pick the one you'd be happy to read a book about. That's usually the one you'll stick with.

General information only, not legal advice. Sources: collectors' column in Weekly View; our permits page, FAQ and site audit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best theme for a beginner?
Western is the easiest. It's classic, there's plenty to choose from and it's easy to display.
Do pirate cap guns need a permit?
Our FAQ treats flintlock-style pieces as an exception in the permit states. Check each listing, and ask us if you're unsure.
Are machine gun cap guns legal to collect?
It depends on your state. Tasmania Police classify imitation machine guns as prohibited firearms needing an exemption, and in NSW an imitation of a prohibited firearm is treated as one. Ring your state police before you buy.
Can I buy a cap gun as a gift for a collector?
Yes, but the person who will own it needs to be legal under their own state's rules. Check first.

Lastest Articles Across Our Guides